Tuesday 21 July 2015

George Adams - Cities: the battle ground between the global financial market forces and the drive for a low carbon future

All human societies fundamentally depend on natural resources and the environment; we now outstrip Earth's natural replenishment capacity by 50%. Climate change has become an ever more irrefutable and urgent issue but still we have no effective international agreement that has any chance of stopping the rise in carbon emissions let alone reduce the levels. What we do have is more conferences and more publications giving the impression to the general public that somewhere the powers that be are solving the big issue. The reality is a continuance of pouring vast sums of money into finding, supplying and consuming more fossil fuels; emissions are predicted to increase by 29% and energy consumption up by 41% by 2035 (BP report 2014).

My questions are these: how do we get local communities to align with the common cause of creating sustainable urban environments, and how do move globally to a new carbon adverse economy to avoid the bigger risk of a future based on fossil fuels.

A longer-term agenda could be about people, their place and surroundings. Local smart solutions could be about Local Authorities, business and communities working together to recognise the responsibilities of location and society with Cities at the heart of this; as we move towards 80% of humanity living in them. The urgency would then be to move forward with the re invention of cities into sustainable, adaptive, healthy and responsible urban communities; able to cope with the inevitable complexities of our future existence.

So I put it to you that our cities will be the battle ground between traditional financial market forces and the urban drive towards essential low carbon smart city economies. It seems to me, the World’s financial markets can't be expected to solve the fossil fuels dependency problem because they simply don't know how to make the big changes quickly enough to avoid the potential for the biggest ever economic meltdown if we continue the current path towards 4 to 6°C of global warming.

We all know there’s been a vast amount of climate change information produced over the past 20 years. But we are in danger of assuming it is producing meaningful action.
The past financial crisis demonstrated what happens when big risks accumulate without adequate management; as indicated by Lord Stern saying the risks are "very big indeed". Sadly it’s not much different today. The so-called "carbon bubble" is a result of an over-valuation of oil, coal and gas reserves held by fossil fuel companies. According to a UCL report in 2014, at least two-thirds of these reserves will have to remain underground if the world is to meet the existing internationally agreed targets to avoid "dangerous" climate change. The recent Earth Day 2015 report concluded that broadly we must keep 75% of all known fossil fuels in the ground.

London, as with many cities, faces future challenges relating to: growth; urbanisation; pollution; resource efficiency; and a changing climate.  London’s population is projected to grow by 12% over the next 20 years. The resulting demands and pressure on energy infrastructure and natural resources obliges city infrastructure providers and consumers to adapt intelligently to ensure efficient, affordable and sustainable solutions. London and other UK cities are with others at the forefront of this change, piloting and pioneering new secure, flexible, low carbon and growth-stimulating urban based solutions that could be cost-effective, smarter, cleaner and locally managed. The difficult organisational system and societal changes need to merge the role of consumers and producers in developing and providing, healthy energy, food, water and mobility integrated solutions that respect the limits of natural resources, the need for total recycling of waste and create cities that integrate strategic urban green landscaping. The real innovation is to join it all up in a holistic systems approach to achieve best value, clean urban environments and sustainable low carbon economies. 
For example the path finding works by the city of Durban. Where transitioning to a low carbon city was the focus of a consensus study from which its report provides 12 key strategic recommendations, as well as sector-specific recommendations, which Durban needs to address in order to transition to a low carbon city.

I believe the issues are beyond international leadership and global conferences now and that a world of local empowered urban communities working in parallel with each other, backed up by enforceable law is likely to provide the fastest and most effective strategy. People are the cause and yet they are also the solution. The Rocky Park community garden scheme in Bethnal Green London which I visited recently is a great example that people can take positive action to green – up their local urban area and bring about better social behaviour.

The role of governments I suggest is to educate and empower cities and urban communities to change and to respond to the biggest conflict and opportunity the human race has ever needed to grasp.

George Adams



Wednesday 1 July 2015

Susie Diamond on the new CIBSE Resilient Cities group


I was drawn to join the new CIBSE Resilient cities group through a funky mixture of curiosity and pessimism regarding the future of our urban environments. Cities have been evolving around the world for centuries at an ever-increasing pace. What they’ll look and feel like to inhabit even in just 50 years is hard to imagine. A large proportion of our current buildings are likely to remain, but interspersed with many new ones, and the way we’ll be using them could be very different. Some of this change could be really exciting, but I am troubled by the uncertainties of climate change and what the implications might be for future generations of city dwellers; how will we manage to maintain the standards of comfort we are used to, and keep using the technology we value without exacerbating climate change?


When this group coalesced we quickly realised that writing a definitive guide for CIBSE members regarding adapting and designing resilient cities was not a realistic proposition. A great deal of work is being done across many sectors to plan and future gaze on this subject, organisations such as The BRE Trust Future Cities Programme, the C40 Cities group and the Future Cities Catapult are just the tip of the iceberg. We therefore felt a more useful remit was to start collating and disseminating the information already out there that is most relevant to CIBSE members, and begin to create some thought leadership regarding what our contribution to the resilience of our cities should be.


“Resilience is the ability of assets, networks and systems to anticipate, absorb, adapt to and / or rapidly recover from a disruptive event.  In its broader sense, it is more than an ability to bounce back and recover from adversity and extends to the broader adaptive capacity gained from an understanding of the risks and uncertainties in our environment.” (Cabinet Office)


One dissemination avenue that this group will be pursuing was inspired by a book edited by Angela Brady, past president of the Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA) and director of Brady Mallalieu Architects Ltd, called The British Papers - Current Thinking on Sustainable City Design (RIBA Publishing). The book is a collection of 31 invited essays that cover a wide variety of topics and themes; and give diverse personal perspectives on the issues and challenges of future city design. Contributors are largely from an architecture background, and their pieces are illustrated, short and relevant. Specifically it’s also a really good read. 


So why not develop the theme and build a similar collection of essays with a more CIBSE focus? We know lots of interesting people within the industry, people with vision and passion, people with a story to share or a new technology to develop.Climate modelling has given us a good idea of where our climate is heading, but there is a wealth of opinion on how this will affect us and how our cities will adapt and evolve to suit these conditions in the late 21st and 22nd centuries. Hearing these voices would be inspiring, thought-provoking (or even enraging) and the ideas presented may be ignored and forgotten or might take hold and ultimately make their way into our thought-processes and the way we practice our work.
Without the resources (yet) to publish a physical book, we are going to invite essayists to write blog posts to publish here as a series that will build up over the coming months. If you’d be interested in contributing to this series then please get in touch with us through: resilientcities@cibse.org